Wednesday, 25 April 2018 16:53

Clap Your Hands and Shout!

1         Clap your hands, all peoples! Shout to God with loud songs of joy!

2         For the LORD, the Most High, is to be feared, a great king over all the earth. (Psa 47:1-2 ESV)

Last month, I wrote about the blessings of singing hymns as a part of our worship, and how the hymnal is a great help in doing that. I am so grateful for this blessing. We are incorporating newer music on Sunday morning as well (some of those new songs are actually hymns!)  It was wonderful how our worship band could put the refrain of “He Will Hold Me Fast” into our hearts and minds.

Hymnals are useful tools. They help us worship together. There are other tools we can use. We can print words, even music into the bulletin. We can sing from memory. The book of psalms is the God-inspired collection of hymns that has been in steady use for centuries. In older times, God’s people would have them memorized.

We can also project the words on a screen. That seems to be what most congregations are doing these days. We project words occasionally at our church, but we are not really set up to do it well.  It is another tool.

Last time, I quoted extensively from an article by Tim Challies. He makes the point that there are pros and cons to our choices in how we present our music. As most have shifted from hymnals to projectors, there are some things that are lost, and some things that are gained.

In April, I shared his thoughts about what we lost. Here is what we gained. These are excerpted from the full article, which you can read here. (Note: he uses “PowerPoint as shorthand for any projection method.)

  • We gained immediacy. Not all of the good songs are old songs...yet hymnals made us wait years or even decades before we could add them to our services... projection reduces the lag between great new songs and updated hymnals.
  • We gained posture. We had to hold the hymnal… and look down at the words…hymnal posture was stiff and fixed. PowerPoint posture is open and free which may be a superior posture for worship, and especially for worship that is physically expressively—something the Bible seems to allow or even advocate.
  • We gained variety. Hymnals promoted certain kinds of songs while holding off others. Yet the Bible gives us freedom to worship in “songs, hymns, and spiritual songs”, to praise God in every variety of song. PowerPoint helps us do this.
  • We gained portability. There is a convenience and portability … that is missing in hymnals. Not only that, but the cost is lower. Two hundred and fifty hymnals will cost around $6,000; a laptop and projector can be had for a fraction of that.
  • We gained spontaneity. PowerPoint allows a kind of spontaneity that may not be present when relying on hymnals.
  • We gained service. Our hymnals reflect a vetting process where hundreds of thousands of hymns were whittled down to just a few hundred..We…serve future generations by singing a variety of today’s songs and, as we do so, filtering the good from the bad and the best from the rest.

We enjoy some of these advantages by using bulletin inserts. I wonder what our singing would be like if we could be looking up, hands free. We couldn’t sing parts as well (although some do that by ear), but we might sing out, and with different kind of togetherness.  Do I dare mention clapping? That needs another article. But, exactly how do we sing Psalm 47?  It’s worth thinking about.

Tools are tools. They have pros and cons. They need to be used thoughtfully and faithfully. Whether the words are in our minds, in hymnals, on bulletin inserts, on screens, on clay tablets or vellum scrolls, we must praise the Lord our God with loud songs of Joy! Sing out!